ADT Self Setup vs. Vivint

ADT and Vivint are both fantastic home security brands. They offer top-of-the-line equipment, full-service professional monitoring, and feature-rich apps for access and control. As a matter of fact, they both headline our list of the best home security systems of 2024.

Today, however, we’re comparing Vivint with one of ADT’s sub-brands called ADT Self Setup. As you might be able to tell from its name, ADT Self Setup is a DIY security system. So how does this self-installed security system from one of the top home security providers compare to one of the best professionally installed systems? We won’t keep you in suspense; let’s dive right in and compare the two.

Key Similarities

• Smart Home Integration: Both brands work well with Alexa and Google Nest, although ADT Self Setup works closer with Google Nest as it offers Google Nest cameras, video doorbells, smart thermostats, and smart speakers and displays as part of its packages.
• Camera Options: Both companies offer three basic camera models – an indoor camera, an outdoor camera, and a doorbell camera. Both also have options for outdoor cameras equipped with security lighting.
• Apps: Both companies also offer responsive, easy-to-use apps that let you control your whole security system with just your voice.

Key Differences

• Pricing: You’ll pay more across the board for Vivint than ADT Self Setup, but that’s because Vivint is a full-service home security company while ADT Self Setup is a DIY system.
• Installation options: ADT Self Setup is self-installed, while Vivint requires professional installation.
• Equipment branding: Vivint uses equipment designed for Vivint systems only. While ADT Self Setup’s sensors are made by ADT, it uses security cameras from Google Nest.

Comparing System Components

Let’s start this comparison by focusing on what you actually get when you sign up with each company.

Both companies offer high-quality equipment including door and window sensors, motion sensors, and a range of cameras. Both systems integrate smoothly with both Alexa and Google Home, so you can connect to additional devices like smart light bulbs, electric blinds, garage doors, and televisions. And, you can control everything with just your voice.

If you look at the entirety of the selection, however, Vivint has a slight edge because it offers more equipment. For example, as we saw in our Vivint review, Vivint has glass break sensors, a carbon monoxide sensor, and its own smart lock from Kwikset. In addition to that, Vivint integrates with third-party smart home devices line Nest and Philips Hue, as well as Z-Wave devices.

On the other hand, ADT Self Setup offers one feature Vivint doesn’t – facial recognition in its security cameras. Also known as Familiar Face Alerts, facial recognition is a staple feature among Nest cameras. You can see how it works in our ADT Self Setup review and our Nest Cam (battery) review.

Vivint hasn’t quite nailed down facial recognition yet, but to its credit, its security cameras are also one of the best security cameras we’ve tested. It has a proactive burglar deterrent feature that uses customizable rules and lights and sound to drive away intruders. You can learn more about it in our Vivint Outdoor Camera Pro review.

Monitoring Options

The real differences between ADT Self Setup and Vivint emerge when we talk about monitoring options.

Let’s start with Vivint. Vivint is a full-service home security company, which means that any time you sign up with the company you’re signing up for 24/7 professional monitoring. You can cancel monitoring at any time, but when you do, you lose access to all of Vivint’s smart features, including app alerts and the ability to view live and recorded footage. Basically, you wind up with a local alarm system and have to rely on sirens to know if anything’s amiss.

We always encourage readers to choose professional monitoring, and here’s why: You never know when you’re going to be too busy to check an alert from your system. You might be at the doctor, stuck in traffic somewhere, or just too engrossed in watching “House of the Dragon” to bother worrying that your phone pinged. With professional monitoring, it doesn’t matter. Someone else checks the alert for you and lets you know if it’s something you need to worry about. In fact, Vivint’s monitoring service will even call emergency personnel to respond if there’s a problem.

As for ADT Self Setup, professional monitoring is also an option, but it’s just that – an option. If you want, you can choose to skip professional monitoring and monitor your system yourself. Going with that option, you’ll receive alerts on your phone but you’d be the one to call the police if needed.

Like we said earlier, we strongly recommend choosing professional monitoring, even though it’s only optional. ADT Self Setup uses the same monitoring network as ADT, and ADT’s monitoring is one of the best ones out there. There are nine monitoring facilities and you’ll get access to SMART Monitoring. The latter is an advanced text-based messaging system that can help homeowners and their family members assess and respond to alerts faster.

Installation

These two companies are also pretty different when it comes to installation. ADT Self Setup only offers DIY installation. Vivint, on the other hand, requires professional installation.

ADT Self Setup is certainly easy to install yourself. Components are all plug and play, sensors stick easily to doors and windows, and everything routes easily through the keypad hub and the mobile app. Our complete guide to installation can even help you make decisions about where to put your cameras.

However, Vivint’s professional installation is relatively affordable, ranging in price from $50-$200 depending on the current promotion and system you purchase. And yes, professional installation means you get to sit back and watch someone else do all the work. Technicians decide on the best places to put everything, and you don’t have to pay a dime extra.

Advantage to Vivint here, with one caveat. If you move, Vivint charges between $50 and $200 to reinstall your equipment at your new home, and you don’t have the option to do it yourself.

Pricing

If you’ve been paying attention up to this point, it will probably come as no surprise that Vivint costs a bit more than ADT costs. That’s because Vivint provides more in terms of services. Let’s break it all down.

Generally speaking, there are three main costs associated with home security systems:

• Equipment costs
• Installation costs
• Monitoring costs

Equipment

If you’re comparing apples to apples, Vivint equipment can be anywhere between two and five times as expensive as ADT Self Setup equipment.

Vivint does allow you to purchase equipment through a financing plan, and the cost is conveniently added to the price of your monitoring plan. That helps to soften the blow of its pricing a little. And, of course, Vivint’s equipment is certainly better quality than ADT Self Setup. We wouldn’t say it’s five times better, though. We’ll call it a tie.

Installation

You won’t pay anything for installation with either of these companies. However, “free” for ADT Self Setup means doing the work yourself, whereas free for Vivint means you actually get something of value for no cost. (Of course, if you move, you’ll pay $50-$200 for Vivint to set your system up in a new location.) However, under most circumstances, we think getting something for nothing is a pretty good deal. Advantage Vivint.

Want more professional installation options? Check out our list of the best professionally installed systems.

Monitoring

There’s a stark difference between ADT Self Setup and Vivint’s monitoring costs. For starters, ADT Self Setup shows you outright how much professional monitoring will cost if you select a package online. With Vivint, you’ll have to go through an entire sales process.

That said, having tried both systems, we can say that ADT Self Setup is definitely cheaper. Basic monitoring starts at $29.99 per month. If you want to add cloud storage for Google Nest cameras, as well as video verification, that will cost you $10 more monthly. And take note: Cloud storage is powered by Nest Aware, which means it comes with all the goodies like facial recognition (Familiar Face Alerts) and customizable motion zones. You can learn more about Nest Aware from our Nest Cam (battery) review.

With Vivint, the monthly cost ranges from around $40 to $60, but again, the price is only final after you go through the sales process. The total monthly cost is dependent on the types of equipment you’ll purchase. For example, adding more security cameras increases your monthly fee as they require a cloud storage subscription.

All in all, we have to give ADT Self Setup the edge when it comes to pricing. But if price isn’t an object for you, then Vivint is the better (and smarter) system.

Recap

So, here’s where things stand: We’ve given the nod to ADT Self Setup when it comes to pricing and monitoring options. Vivint, though, wins in the categories of installation and equipment. Does that make it a toss up?

Sort of. If you remember how this page started, you’ll know we said these are both great companies that offer great products. However, those products are also different. The bottom line, then, is that you have to go with the one that’s going to meet your specific needs.

If you want simple and affordable home protection without sacrificing features, then go with ADT Self Setup. If you want the best-of-the-best smart home security system to protect you and yours, then Vivint is the way to go.